As to the where and when this happened, note that most versions of this bootleg floating around the Internet claim it took place at Queens College in New York City some time in 1964. At first, that would make sense, because Simon graduated from Queens College in 1963 with a major in English. But and it looks like he didn't play in public in the US at all that year. He spent most of the year trying to start a music career in England, only occasionally coming back to the US to record or mix the first Simon and Garfunkel album, "Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M." By contrast, he played dozens of venues in England in 1964, and one of them was a girls' school in London called Queen's College. So I strongly suspect there was a confusion between the two places with the similar names (one with an apostrophe and one without).
SoundBoard Recording mono
Sound A-+
1 CDs
1-Scarborough Fair
2-The House Carpenter Song
3-Gospel Ship
4-Pretty Boy Floyd
5-A Church Is Burning
6-The Sounds Of Silence
7-Leaves That Are Green
8-The Sun Is Burning
9-Can't Help But Wonder Where I'm Bound
10-Going To The Zoo
11-He Was My Brother
12-Thank You